notices - See details
Notices

Weighing the cost of resilient supply chains

Aerial view of a cargo ship carrying colourful shipping containers passing beneath a road bridge, with a freight truck crossing above and a tugboat nearby, illustrating the interconnected nature of global supply chains and international trade.
Published 16 Nov 2026

Key takeaways

Supply-chain resilience requires targeted investment that balances disruption risks, financial returns and opportunities for competitive advantage.

  • Spending is most effective when focused on critical dependencies where recovery takes longer than the business can withstand.
  • Qualified alternatives, flexible contracts and shared capacity can strengthen resilience without duplicating entire production networks.
  • Investors should assess supplier dependencies, response capabilities and performance during disruptions, alongside company disclosures.


Investing in resilience does not always produce a positive return. What lessons can investors take from the way businesses approach resilience in their supply chains?

A string of supply chain disruptions in recent years - from pandemic shutdowns to semiconductor shortages, and geopolitical trade restrictions to extreme weather events — has made resilience a pressing boardroom priority.

The shift towards resilience is a departure from the logic that governed supply chains for most of the previous three decades: minimize cost, reduce inventory and concentrate production in the cheapest locations. 

For many international businesses, the question now is not whether to invest in resilience, but how to do it economically.

"Companies are increasingly treating resilience as a financial investment," said Lorenzo Capucci, a supply chain and geopolitics expert at Boston Consulting Group. "They calculate net present values, they assess the risk they are avoiding. And sometimes the analysis tells you it is better to accept the risk and deliberately price it in, because the resilience investment does not yield good returns."

Figure 1: Trade Policy Uncertainty has Spiked Persistently elevated trade policy uncertainty 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 Index (100= 1% Article Share) US-China
 Trade War Average Average Trump’s
 Inauguration Liberation
 Day 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 Source: Caldara, Dario, Matteo lacoviello, Patrick Molligo, Andrea Prestipino, and Andrea Raffo, "The Economic Effects of Trade Policy Uncertainty," revised November 2019, Journal of Monetary Economics. As of March 3, 2026. The trade policy uncertainty index (TPU) is constructed by staff in the International Finance Division of the Federal Reserve Board and measures media attention to news related to trade policy uncertainty. Source: Trade Policy Uncertainty Index


The most common mistake, according to Sora Utzinger, Senior ESG Research Analyst at Morgan Stanley, is treating resilience as a uniform requirement rather than a targeted one. "There is no universal resilience ratio," she said. The right framework is instead to assess impact tolerance at each critical point in the supply chain. "Fundamentally, the question is: how long can this element be unavailable before customer relationships, safety obligations or cash flow are materially impaired?"

That question produces two key metrics, Utzinger explained: time-to-survive and time-to-recover. The first measures how long the business can continue using existing inventory or spare capacity. The second measures how long it would take to restart supply or activate an alternative.

Where time-to-recover exceeds time-to-survive, there is a resilience gap. Closing that gap might mean additional inventory, a qualified alternative supplier, or faster recovery capability. Utzinger cautioned, however, that "a blanket requirement to dual-source every single item would be uneconomic and deeply inefficient."

IMF modelling suggests that diversification is most valuable when targeted at shock-exposed, upstream and difficult-to-reconfigure inputs, rather than applied indiscriminately across the supply chain. Prime examples include semiconductors and rare earth elements - both geographically concentrated and structurally resistant to rapid reconfiguration.

Capucci described the same principle operationally. "Less and less, companies are targeting a fully resilient supply chain end to end," he said. "More and more, they are digging deeper to understand what is the 20% of inputs that can really stop their production line - and concentrating their resilience spend there."

Capucci offered a stark example of a wider pattern: companies tend to defend against the shock they have already experienced rather than the one ahead of them. Following the COVID-era shortage of advanced semiconductors, many automotive companies channeled resources into securing those complex, high-function chips - a rational response to the disruption they had just lived through.

When Nexperia’s supply of discrete semiconductors - inexpensive, single-function chips that run basic functions such as door locks and speedometers - came under threat in late 2025, it exposed how little attention automakers had paid to these simpler components.

The issue was less their technical complexity than the combination of supplier concentration and switching time. Nexperia holds around 40% of the global market in transistors and diodes, with its assembly and test operations concentrated at a single site in China. And because these chips are soldered directly into components, automotive-grade requalification of an alternative takes months rather than weeks.

How do businesses structure investments in resilience?

Capucci identified three design approaches adopted by companies achieving a strong return on investment (ROI) in resilience:

  1. Segmentation: Concentrating investment at genuinely critical nodes rather than applying a uniform policy across the entire bill of materials.
  2. Optionality over redundancy: Having qualified alternatives, dual-approved parts and contractual rights to shift volumes, rather than committing to a second facility that must be paid for whether used or not.
  3. Shared capacity: In periods of heightened geopolitical uncertainty, saturating existing buffer capacity or sharing manufacturing floor space with peers, rather than pursuing greenfield investment.

Figure 2: Top Strategic Supply Chain Changes Planned for 2026 51% Increase suppliers
 (diversify sourcing base) 36% Friendshore operations (shift
 to allied or partner countries) 32% Nearshore operations (move
 closer to or home markets) 18% Decrease suppliers
 (consolidate sourcing base) 18% Decrease inventories 31% Insource operations 28% Outsource operations 44% Increase inventories Share of respondents Supply chain executives were asked: What are the top three strategic supply chain changes your company plans to make in 2026? Select three. 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% Source: DP World Global Trade Observatory Executive Survey, November 2025


Getting the design right is only part of the challenge. Kai Trepte, a Research Affiliate at the MIT Center for Transport and Logistics, identified a more fundamental problem in how companies approach resilience investments: a persistent boom-bust cycle. Companies invest heavily after a major disruption, then cut back as the memory fades and cost pressures return. "We are progressively over and under investing," he said.

The solution he and his co-authors developed - drawing on earlier work by MIT researchers in collaboration with Cisco - is a real options framework for resilience investment that evaluates resilience actions against a probability-weighted distribution of outcomes rather than specific events.

"Stop thinking about specific events," said Trepte. "Think about how often you lose your supply, regardless of where it comes from, and how long it takes you to recover. It’s the distribution of outcomes that matters, not the specific event." Using a large pharmaceutical supply chain as a case study, Trepte and his co-authors found that sustained, option-framed investment programs outperform reactive, crisis-driven spending.

Can resilience create a competitive advantage?

The investment case becomes more compelling when resilience moves beyond risk avoidance into value creation. According to the World Economic Forum’s Global Value Chains Outlook 2026, 74% of business leaders now view resilience as a driver of growth rather than a cost. 

During a market-wide shortage, a company that can continue supplying customers may win market share, gain preferred-supplier status, improve pricing and product mix, or secure longer-term contracts.

Capucci pointed to Toyota’s experience during the Nexperia shortage as a case study in targeted resilience. After Japan’s 2011 earthquake and tsunami severely disrupted its supply chains, Toyota implemented a systematic program requiring suppliers to stockpile critical semiconductor components - a practice some analysts had questioned as unnecessarily tying up working capital. But as the Nexperia crisis unfolded, Toyota’s CEO reported no immediate shortage, whereas other major automakers suspended production or warned the disruption could threaten annual profit targets.

Utzinger noted that resilience capabilities can also improve performance in normal times. Better visibility across the supply chain can reduce excess inventory, closer supplier collaboration can improve quality and innovation, and earlier risk detection can reduce premium freight costs. "Resilience and efficiency are not necessarily opposites," she said.
 

What should investors look for when assessing resilience?

Unlike with climate risk, there is no standardized framework requiring companies to disclose their supply chain vulnerabilities. “Nobody is mandated to disclose their time-to-switch on critical inputs,” said Capucci. “You are not forced to disclose your single-site dependencies or your indirect supplier concentration.”

Utzinger laid out a three-layer framework for investors assessing whether a company’s supply chain is genuinely resilient:

  1. Architecture: Where are the real dependencies — not just with direct suppliers, but in intellectual property, critical minerals and upstream inputs?
  2. Capability: Can the company actually respond when conditions change — does it have the data, decision rights and rehearsed playbooks to act quickly? “A second supplier that has not been qualified yet is not a genuine option,” she noted.
  3. Outcomes: What happened when the system was tested? “Investors should avoid scoring disclosure quality in isolation and instead test whether the disclosure corresponds to an actual operational capability,” she said.


Trepte said investors can do substantial preliminary work using publicly available information, mapping geographic concentration of manufacturing and assessing exposure to climate events, tariff risk and geopolitical disruption. The goal is not to measure resilience precisely but to rank companies by their relative exposure and preparedness.
 


Utzinger put the key consideration for investors plainly: “Inventory is easy for a competitor to copy. Trusted supplier relationships, modular products, high-quality data and fast decision-making are not.” The companies building those less-replicable capabilities are the ones most likely to convert supply chain resilience from a cost into a durable competitive edge, she said.
 

Explore the full series to see how trade flows are shaping investment trends:

Want to learn more about Private markets?

Explore our selection of professional learning options, research, and thought leadership designed to help you advance your private markets career with confidence.

Learn more
Abstract private markets illustration